Question: How should we calculate
Zakah on stocks and shares?
Answer: Before I answer this question,
let me draw your attention to an important aspect regarding its calculation:
One of the heads on which Zakah was levied in the time of the Prophet
(sws) was on the harvested crop. It is evident that, contrary to wealth
(on which Zakah was levied annually at the rate of 2.5 %), crops
form a different category. While in the former, no production is taking
place, the latter are actually a form of produce. On crops grown on rainy
lands, Zakah was levied at the rate of 10 % of the produce at the
time of produce, while on lands which needed human effort for water supply
to grow crops, it was levied at the rate of 5 % of the produce at the time
of produce. In other words, if the spirit of this directive is kept in
consideration, Zakah on any form of produce is either 10 % or 5%,
whatever be its nature. In the times of the Prophet (sws), since agricultural
produce was the only form of produce, therefore Zakah was imposed
on it on the above mentioned rates. Today by analogy, it should be levied
at these very rates on any other form of produce. Industrial produce, in
these times, for example is a very common form of produce.
As far as the difference in the two rates of produce
(5% and 10%) is concerned, it is evident that where human effort is very
little – that is it is confined to sowing seeds only and where water is
actually supplied through rains, the rate of Zakah is more, ie 10%.
On the contrary, where this effort is considerable, the rate is reduced
to 5 %. In other words, if one derives the principle underlying this calculation,
one can safely conclude that Zakah on all items which are produced
both by the interaction of labour and capital is 5%, and on items which
are produced such that the basic factor in producing them is either labour
or capital, it is 10%.
It also needs to be appreciated that all the tools of
production are exempted from Zakah.
With this background, I now come to your question. By
analogy, earning money through stocks seems to be a form of produce in
which no labour is involved. It is the case of production made through
capital only. If this derivation is true, then Zakah should be levied
at the rate of 10 % on the dividend earned. The total amount invested in
stocks is, of course, exempt from Zakah since it is basically the
tool of production.
(Shehzad Saleem)
|